Fair's fair Permanent link to this item in the archive.

To be fair, the people giving Dave Winer a hard time over his comments about Blogher should be as concerned over comments such as this by Maryam Scoble, which was partly what prompted my suggestion of tableturning. Of course there has since been quite a lot of tableturning talk.

Meanwhile, one of the responders to Liz Henry's post, Madeline F, suggests being called a sexist is descriptive, not an insult. That's too slippery for me. The simple test is to ask the person being described that way if they feel hurt. It seems Dave does.

Also in those posts is OhPun's characterization of most men as having only limited skills in communication and understanding.

'However, most males do not know how to talk. Period. They can't talk to women and truly they can't talk to other men either. However, since most other men can't talk back, grunting and pointing is considered "conversation."'
Maryam's belief that (unlike men) women can't be geeks because women 'as hard ass as they can be in the technical field still have some RAM left for the soft stuff', also makes a claim for the superiority of women in their complexity and emotional intactness. As I've commented before, I don't accept the idea that men are essentially one-dimensional and without a significant emotional life, and I think in practice it's quite damaging to the relationships between men and women, and the cause of feminism.